Saturday, 28 November 2015, 12:37pm
ECB decision to make county coin toss not mandatory met with mixed reviews
In both tiers of next season's County Championship, the visiting captain will be given the option of bowling first which, if he chooses to take, will see the toss rendered unnecessary.
A coin will only be spun - as has been cricket's tradition for over a hundred years - if the visiting captain rejects the chance to bowl first.
The proposal was passed - on the basis of a one-year trial - at an ECB board meeting at Lord's on Thursday and cricket committee head Peter Wright said the move came about partly as a result of concerns about the development of English spinners.
Rather than home teams now winning the toss and unleashing a seam-heavy attack on a pitch which makes batting hazardous, the away captain will now have the option to intervene.
The move has not been met with unanimous approval, though.
Yorkshire captain Andrew Gale - who has a fine seam battery at his disposal and has lifted the County Championship for the last two seasons - called the move madness.
"So no coin toss next year if away team doesn't want it?! absolute madness," he said on Twitter.
Gale added: "2018, batters aren't allowed pads either and bowlers can only come off 5 steps!!"
Former England captain Michael Vaughan - whose successor Andrew Strauss was involved in the decision - added that the ECB should simply employ its own groundsmen at venues rather than tinker with the rules.
"Why don't you just employ all the groundsman @ECB_cricket ?? Would safe (sic) the need for any radical changes..!!?" he wrote.
Ex-England opener Mark Butcher backed Vaughan's opposition, saying that better bowlers would lessen the need for change.
"Toss is not the problem. Volume of quality bowlers is the problem. change everything but the thing that will solve the problem," he said on Twitter.
But Wright insisted that the need to find spinners was not the only reason behind the switch.
"It isn't all about spin," he said. "There has been concern for some years about some Championship pitches. But it is fair to say that the plight of spin bowling in this country brought things into focus.
"Figures showing that spinners bowled only 21.5 per cent of the overs in the 2015 Championship were presented to the committee and we have come to the conclusion that the only way to bring spin bowlers more into the game is to provide better pitches for them to bowl on.
"Of course counties want to win matches, and that generally means taking 20 wickets. That has to be a reason we have seen a lot of pitches that start a bit green and damp, and get better as the game goes on, rather than deteriorating to help the spinners.
"But another main function of the County Championship is to develop players for England. We don't think it has been serving that purpose for spinners.
"By giving the away team the option of bowling first, we hope the home side will be encouraged to produce the best possible four-day pitch. That will be good for cricket in general, and not only for spinners: batsmen should also benefit from better pitches which will lead to them facing more spin bowling; and if pitches start drier, the ball may scuff up a bit more and produce more reverse swing."
The recommendation came from the ECB's cricket committee, which includes the like of chief executive Tom Harrison, England team director Strauss and former coach Andy Flower.
"Our cricket committee possesses a vast range of technical expertise and playing experience," Wright said.
"We can draw on a wealth of cricketing knowledge both within the domestic first-class game and from people who have extensive experience of the international game.
"We will then need to assess how successful the trial has been at the end of the 2016 season before deciding whether to continue with this."
Copyright (c) Press Association Ltd. 2015, All Rights Reserved.
The ECB is removing the toss if the visiting captain agrees